Monday, 16 November 2026

AI Worries Outweigh Strong Economic Data

In a week that once again featured solid economic data, stocks faltered as investors continued to question the sustainability of the AI boom. This came in the context of the U.S. midterm elections, which saw the Democrats decisively take control of both the House and the Senate and win numerous gubernatorial races—even in traditionally Republican states. Stocks opened the post-election period with a sharp relief rally on Wednesday, albeit with AI-related names posting declines. That gave way to a broad rout on Thursday, when nearly every nook and cranny of the financial markets saw losses and the tech-heavy Nasdaq 100 fell 6.4 percent, wiping out a record $2.3 trillion in market value in a single day. Markets recovered some of those losses on Friday, but the S&P 500 still finished the week down 2.68 percent, led by losses in industrials (-2.83 percent), technology (-6.93 percent), and energy, which fell 11.93 percent on hopes that the U.S. and Iran could reach a deal.

The data released last week built on previous weeks and showed an economy that is still broadly pushing forward. The ISM Manufacturing Index rose to 55.5 from 54.5 (figures above 50 indicate growth), which, aside from a 55.6 reading in May, was the highest level since May 2022. Production also spiked to 59, the highest level since November 2021. The ISM Services Index remained in expansion even though it pulled back slightly to 54.5 from last month’s 54.9, leaving the economy-weighted ISM at 54.6, down from 54.9 and 55.3 in the previous two months but still at the highest levels since September 2022. The bad news is that the economy-weighted Prices Index remained at 73.2, down slightly from last month’s 74.3 but (aside from that September reading) still the highest level since June 2022. Indeed, data going back to 1997 shows only 7 percent of the 352 observations have been higher, and they have occurred in periods of heightened inflation.

The labor market report was equally strong and broad. Payrolls rose 165,000 versus the 70,000 expected, and the September number was revised higher to 60,000 from 29,000, part of a two-month revision that added 84,000. Private payrolls rose 159,000, with the previous month revised higher to 78,000 from 46,000, while manufacturing added 19,000 after a 13,000 gain. Hiring remained spread across multiple industries, with the one-month diffusion index holding above 50 for the 10th month in a row, while the three-month diffusion index rose to 60.4 from 58.6—the highest since June 2023. The unemployment rate fell to 4.1 percent from 4.2 percent.

However, strong data is being outmatched by AI concerns, which are real given the significant role AI has played in recent U.S. economic and stock market growth. The more technology-focused indices outside the S&P 500 highlight damage in many pockets of the industry that reflect these concerns. The Nasdaq 100 fell 4.91 percent, the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index (SOX) fell another 12.15 percent, and the Goldman Sachs (GS) basket of AI stocks fell another 11.36 percent. Technology and AI stocks began peaking on June 22, although a few indices did not set their highs until October 6. The Nasdaq 100 is now in correction territory, down 13.56 percent from its October high, while the SOX and the broader GS AI basket are down 35.84 percent and 31.84 percent, respectively, from their June 22 highs.

The S&P 500 technology sector has also fallen into correction territory, down 15.90 percent from its October 6 high, with 41 of its 76 members losing more than the index. Many heavyweight stocks remain well below their all-time highs, including NVIDIA, which is off 21.98 percent, Advanced Micro Devices (AMD) off 30.85 percent, Broadcom off 39.01 percent, and Micron off 43.14 percent. Despite these sharp moves lower, the good news is that other parts of the equity market are holding up and cushioning the blow for investors who have remained diversified. The S&P 500 is off only 5.6 percent from its October high, with seven of its 11 sectors positive since then, led by the defensive staples and health care sectors. Meanwhile, the S&P equal weight is only 3.2 percent off its recent high.

With many stocks falling sharply, some commentators argue that they now look cheap. But markets are forward looking, and the concern is likely the sustainability of companies’ future earnings streams. Those valuations largely reflect incredible earnings growth over the past few years, much of it tied to a booming AI buildout that may be slowing, which raises the question of whether AI spending is at a peak. Last week, the AI concerns we have highlighted recently gained another dimension. The blue wave in the U.S. midterm elections raises the prospect of a slowdown in data-center construction, and on Tuesday voters favored restrictions on data-center development in 40 of 41 local ballot measures, according to Ballotpedia tracking.

This potential slowdown in construction comes as questions grow about the cost of bringing AI to life. Despite strong third-quarter nonfarm productivity, which rose at an annualized rate of 3.6 percent and that some said likely reflected benefits from AI, reports indicate that large companies continue to place limits on AI usage. Apple was reported to have cut its daily AI spending cap for some engineers to $200 from $300, with a reduction to $100 under consideration. It joins Microsoft, Tesla, Uber, and Meta in capping employee usage. After months of “tokenmaxxing,” the ironic result is that the biggest users of AI are now rationing it, which raises the question of when the profits will justify the spending. At the same time, these companies are borrowing to fund AI rollouts, with Apple ($7.5 billion), Microsoft ($25 billion), Oracle ($10 billion), and Meta ($15 billion) all issuing debt last week. With that much borrowing underway, the cost of capital matters even more.

The other swing factor is the Federal Reserve, which is likely to have a significant impact on what happens going forward. Does it raise interest rates and risk pushing the cost of capital higher, or does it hold steady? Despite the strong economic data, bond yields fell again last week, and the odds of a rate hike also moved with the stock market. They stood at 81.8 percent on Wednesday, fell to 68.4 percent on Thursday when stocks sold off, and rose back to 77 percent on Friday as stocks recovered some of those losses, reducing from 90 percent on October 19. That is the reality of how large the U.S. stock market has become—2.15 times the size of the national economy, just off a record 2.3 times—and with the wealth effect helping power spending, it is likely to play a huge role in what the Fed does on December 9.

The University of Michigan survey shows just how important that wealth effect has become. The median value of stock market investments among respondents has climbed to $388,000—up from $100,000-$150,000 from the end of 2013 to February 2024. With that much wealth in the market, sentiment has become closely tied to it. All of this is happening even with signs of inflation still evident, which is going to mean a hard decision for the Fed at its next meeting—raising rates would risk further pressure on the AI trade and the economy as a whole if markets continue to wobble. That is the circle we’ve mentioned before: AI-driven market gains have supported stock wealth, confidence, and spending; and similarly, AI-driven market stress can feed right back into the economy.

Where the AI market is heading remains unknown, and several questions are still unanswered. Is AI spending peaking? Will the profits justify the cost? Will data-center pushback and tighter capital slow the buildout? And how does the Fed respond if inflation remains elevated? Even consumers are starting to ask, with University of Michigan respondents showing a sharp increase in mentions of a potential AI bubble.

Unfortunately, no one knows for certain if it is a bubble, and market movements over the past few months indicate that some air has already come out of the AI trade. This is where we continue to point to diversification as the antidote to heightened uncertainty in both the economy and financial markets. The benefits of diversification have been on display as the market has rotated, with AI and technology-related stocks faltering while other areas have held up, in large part because economic data has remained strong. However, if AI concerns continue to grow and the slowdown proves sharper, it is likely in to spill over into more parts of the market in the near term, as it did on Thursday.

Even so, we continue to believe that investors who stay diversified and true to a financial plan will be rewarded in the intermediate to longer term. Comparisons to the dot-com era are likely to grow in the coming months, and as in that period, the value chain should shift from those who built AI to the companies that use it, with the entire economy benefiting from increased productivity.

Lessons from that period also show us how diversification can lead to better performance. In the years after the market peaked in early 2000, a globally diversified equity portfolio—one that includes the S&P 500, U.S. small- and mid-caps, real estate investment trusts (REITs), and international stocks—weathered the storm and pushed higher, even as the Nasdaq and the S&P technology sector took 14.5 and 16.8 years to reach new highs, as the chart below shows. While we don’t know if history will repeat itself, we do believe diversified, long-term investors who stick to a financial plan will once again be rewarded for their patience.

About the Author:

Brent Schutte, CFA, is chief investment officer of the Northwestern Mutual Wealth Management Company.

The Most Read

Latest

How To Make Mistakes Feel Safer This School Year
How To Help Prepare for Your Child's Unpredictable Future
AI Worries Outweigh Strong Economic Data
How the Sandwich Generation Can Help Protect Aging Parents’ Finances
Hollaway Wins Over Incumbent Rojas in Carson’s District 4 As She Congratulates Him; Dear Easily Wins Re-Election
Exit mobile version