A proposed California ballot initiative would eliminate the state’s open primary election system and restore partisan primaries for congressional and statewide offices, reopening a long-running debate over voter choice and political representation.
The measure, titled “Undo the Top Two,” was submitted to state officials by political consultant Steve Maviglio, who is requesting a circulating title and summary for the proposal. If approved by voters, the initiative would reverse election reforms adopted in 2010 that created California’s current “top two” primary structure.
Under the existing system, all voters can choose any candidate in a primary election regardless of party affiliation. The two candidates receiving the highest number of votes advance to the general election, even if both belong to the same political party.
Supporters of the initiative argue the system has failed to achieve its original goals. In the proposal’s findings section, backers said Californians were promised the open primary would reduce political division, limit the influence of special interests and encourage cooperation among elected officials.
“The experiment failed,” the initiative states, arguing that political polarization has worsened in both Sacramento and Washington, D.C., while special interests continue to wield strong influence over elections and policymaking.
The proposal also argues that the current system limits voter choice by sometimes producing general elections featuring two candidates from the same political party. Supporters say that outcome can leave some voters without a candidate who reflects their political beliefs.
If enacted, the initiative would amend the California Constitution to remove language establishing the “top two” system. Political parties would once again be allowed to advance their highest-performing candidates from party primaries into the general election.
The effort comes as California prepares for another crowded statewide election cycle, including a highly competitive governor’s race that has drawn dozens of candidates. Concerns that two Republicans could advance to the general election have renewed criticism of the current primary structure in the heavily Democratic state.
Critics of repealing the system have argued the open primary encourages broader participation and produces more moderate candidates by allowing independents and crossover voters to participate in primary contests.
Maviglio previously served as communications director for former Gov. Gray Davis and managed the mayoral campaign of former Sacramento Mayor Kevin Johnson. The proposal must gather enough valid signatures before qualifying for a future statewide ballot.
____________
Article By: Bo Tefu, California Black Media
